When it comes to iconic small dogs, few breeds capture hearts quite like the Scottish Terrier — bold, loyal, and brimming with personality. But how does this little powerhouse compare to other popular dog breeds? Whether you’re a first-time dog owner or an experienced terrier enthusiast, this guide will help you decide if the Scottish Terrier is truly the right fit for your home.
In this comprehensive comparison, we’ll explore how Scotties stack up against 10 other famous breeds — from Corgis to Westies — covering their size, temperament, exercise needs, shedding levels, and trainability.
Let’s dive in! 🐶👇
🦴 1. Scottish Terrier vs. Airedale Terrier
Battle of the Terriers! Both Scottish Terriers and Airedales were bred for hunting, but their size and energy levels set them apart.
| Feature | Scottish Terrier | Airedale Terrier |
|---|---|---|
| Size | 19–22 lbs, compact and muscular | 40–60 lbs, large and athletic |
| Coat | Thick, wiry double coat | Harsh, wire-haired coat |
| Shedding | Low | Moderate |
| Exercise | Prefers short walks | Needs open space and daily activity |
| Temperament | Bold, loyal, and independent | Confident, calm, and easier to train |
💡 Quick Tip: If you live in an apartment, the Scottish Terrier is easier to manage. Airedales, however, thrive in homes with yards and active owners.
🐾 2. Scottish Terrier vs. Corgi
Both small and full of charm, but their personalities differ.
| Feature | Scottish Terrier | Corgi |
|---|---|---|
| Size | 19–22 lbs | 22–28 lbs |
| Coat | Double coat | Double coat |
| Shedding | Low | Heavy |
| Temperament | Fiercely independent | Social and friendly |
| Trainability | Stubborn | Highly trainable |
💬 Verdict: Corgis are ideal for families who want a social and playful companion. Scottish Terriers suit those who admire confidence and independence.
🐶 3. Scottish Terrier vs. Dachshund
The two share short legs but very different temperaments.
| Feature | Scottish Terrier | Dachshund |
|---|---|---|
| Size | 19–22 lbs | 16–32 lbs |
| Coat | Double coat | Single or double, depending on variety |
| Exercise | Moderate | Moderate |
| Temperament | Alert, brave, independent | Loyal but shy with strangers |
| Trainability | Hard to train | Slightly easier |
🦴 Fun Fact: Both breeds are hunters at heart, but Dachshunds love burrowing — while Scotties love guarding.
🐕 4. Scottish Terrier vs. French Bulldog
One is a proud hunter, the other a couch-loving companion.
| Feature | Scottish Terrier | French Bulldog |
|---|---|---|
| Size | 19–22 lbs | 16–28 lbs |
| Coat | Double coat | Single coat |
| Shedding | Low | Moderate |
| Energy | Active | Relaxed |
| Trainability | Difficult | Moderate |
💡 Takeaway: If you love active walks and mental challenges, pick a Scottie. If you prefer a chill, affectionate pet, the French Bulldog is your soulmate.
🦮 5. Scottish Terrier vs. Jack Russell Terrier
A face-off between two high-energy terriers!
| Feature | Scottish Terrier | Jack Russell |
|---|---|---|
| Size | 19–22 lbs | 13–17 lbs |
| Coat | Thick, wiry | Smooth or rough |
| Exercise | Moderate | High |
| Temperament | Calm but stubborn | Playful and outgoing |
| Trainability | Moderate difficulty | Easier with rewards |
💬 Verdict: Choose a Jack Russell if you love non-stop action. Go with a Scottie for a mix of loyalty and independence.
🧠 6. Scottish Terrier vs. Schnauzer
Two intelligent, alert breeds — but with different social needs.
| Feature | Scottish Terrier | Schnauzer |
|---|---|---|
| Size | 19–22 lbs | 35–45 lbs |
| Coat | Thick, wiry double coat | Coarse double coat |
| Temperament | Independent | People-oriented |
| Exercise | Moderate | High |
| Trainability | Stubborn | Easier to train |
💡 Note: Schnauzers love attention and thrive in busy homes. Scotties enjoy calm environments and one-on-one bonds.
🐾 7. Scottish Terrier vs. West Highland Terrier (Westie)
Two Scottish icons with similar looks but opposite personalities!
| Feature | Scottish Terrier | Westie |
|---|---|---|
| Size | 19–22 lbs | 15–22 lbs |
| Coat | Double coat | Double coat |
| Shedding | Low | Moderate |
| Temperament | Independent | Outgoing and friendly |
| Trainability | Harder | Easier |
❤️ Verdict: Westies are cheerful extroverts, while Scotties are dignified introverts. Both make excellent companions!
🐩 8. Scottish Terrier vs. Yorkshire Terrier
Small but mighty — both breeds have big personalities.
| Feature | Scottish Terrier | Yorkie |
|---|---|---|
| Size | 19–22 lbs | 4–7 lbs |
| Coat | Thick, wiry double coat | Long, silky single coat |
| Energy | High | Very high |
| Shedding | Low | Low |
| Trainability | Harder | Moderate |
💬 Summary: Yorkies are better for apartment dwellers wanting a playful lap dog. Scotties suit owners who admire independence and boldness.
🏁 Final Verdict: Which Breed Wins?
If you want a dog that’s brave, loyal, and fiercely independent, the Scottish Terrier is unbeatable.
But if you want a social, easy-to-train, or relaxed companion, other breeds like the Westie, Schnauzer, or French Bulldog may fit your lifestyle better.
Whichever you choose — you’ll gain a loyal best friend for life. ❤️🐾
📚 Pro Tips to Remember
- Regular grooming keeps the Scottie’s coat sharp and healthy.
- Early socialization reduces stubbornness and barking.
- Provide mental challenges — Scotties love puzzle toys and agility games!
🧭 Conclusion
The Scottish Terrier stands out as a fearless, dignified, and loving companion for those who appreciate a strong-willed pet. With proper training, attention, and affection, a Scottie will reward you with endless loyalty and unforgettable charm.